Job phrases his reply to Zophar in words that include the arguments raised by Eliphaz and Bildad. Perhaps they had good intentions for what they said, concerned as they are with Job’s healing. Yet they have accused him of foolishness, arrogance and stupidity. Job tells them that he is as wise as they. He knows all their arguments, all their wisdom. Yet he admits he knows one thing more: his experience has told him that the rigid idea of God’s retributive justice is belied by experience. His own suffering tells him that the righteous indeed suffer bad things for no apparent reason.
In addition, as Job observes the world God’s ways seem arbitrary and inexplicable. Wicked men prosper unmolested, while the good and the innocent are oppressed, enslaved and subjected to a multitude of sorrows. Job also sees great injustice as he observes the animal world. Tame, docile creatures such as sheep, cows and goats all are victimized by ravenous predators without cause simply because this is how God made them. Finally Job notes that kingdoms and rulers rise and fall without any valid explanation. Good nations rise only to fall to the might of wicked ones which fall victim to those even more wicked. Job essentially feels that God does as He pleases and this seems unjust. As Job wrestles with this inconsistency, his thinking leads him to conclude that God is much more mysterious and infinitely vast than he previously thought. His ways are not ours.